Showing posts with label support. Show all posts
Showing posts with label support. Show all posts

Friday, December 24, 2010

A higher level of barriers

In a previous post, I talked about the most common reasons moms quit breastfeeding: latching problems, breast refusal, low milk supply, and pain.   Looking back, I realize that I stopped because of extreme pain caused by latching problems from extreme engorgement and a frenetically, energetically hungry baby with a very strong suck.

United States Breastfeeding Committee commissioned a new report to help "combat the barriers to breastfeeding success."  It lists the major barriers as "hospital practices, provider skills, social and workplace support, and media and marketing."  These are the societal barriers that either cause or hinder solutions to the many personal or physiological problems (like pain) that new moms deal with when trying to breastfeed.

At the time my son was born, I felt that my hospital gave me good support, I think because I was so emotionally overwhelmed that I mistook good emotional care for good medical care.  (The hospital where Sam was born is not recognized as a Baby-Friendly Hospital by Unicef, though they did meet many of the Ten Steps.)  But with a year of hindsight, asking myself whether the medical services did the best they could for me and my baby, the answer is no. Here's why:
  1. There was one lactation consultant on staff at the hospital, but she was also a full-time nurse with regular shifts and only saw nursing moms in her spare time between rounds or as overtime.  During my stay at the hospital, I saw her once a day, and afterward, once a week.  What I needed was access to a certified lactation consultant round the clock while at the hospital (anytime I tried to nurse) and on call at home.  Initiating breastfeeding is an hour-by-hour challenge.
  2. The other nurses tried to help with breastfeeding, but their advice was, though well-meaning, inconsistent and not very helpful, except for the emotional aspect.   A commonly-cited article from the Journal of Obstetric, Gynecological, and Neonatal Nursing reported that "nurses have limited knowledge of breastfeeding, although no variable consistently predicted breastfeeding knowledge."  (Anderson, 1991.)
  3. The nurses gave Samuel colostrum mixed with glucose water, despite medical recommendations against glucose water to prevent hypoglycemia.  (Orr, 1997.) 
  4. One of my symptoms was edema, which made engorgement worse and latching extremely difficult.  The lactation consultant said the IV fluids I was given contributed to this, but I don't recall edema being one of the potential side effects of my pain treatment.  (Walker, 2000.)
  5. I expected my doula to see when there was a problem and help me find solutions, but her job was done after the baby was born, except for one follow-up visit.  Next time I will secure my own help (from doula or otherwise) for longer.
These fall under "hospital services" and "provider skills," I could also list other problems I experienced under "social and workplace support" and probably even "media and marketing."  What combination of problems did you experience, and which of the higher-level barriers (hospital practices, provider skills, social and workplace support, and media and marketing) did they fall under?

1. Orr, Edie and Crase, B.  "Hypoglycemia and the Breastfed Newborn." From NEW BEGINNINGS, Vol. 14 No. 4, July-August 1997, pp. 107-8
2.  Anderson, E., N, MS and GEDEN, E., RN, PhD, FAAN.  "Nurses' Knowledge of Breastfeeding."  Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, & Neonatal Nursing, Volume 20, Issue 1, pages 58–62, January 1991.
3. Walker, Marsha, RN, IBCLC.   "Breastfeeding and Engorgement.  from Breastfeeding Abstracts, November 2000, Volume 20, Number 2, pp. 11-12.

Sunday, May 9, 2010

Supply

The second biggest reason moms choose to formula-feed is not being able to tell if the baby is getting enough milk, according to the same article (Arora, 2000) that cited fathers' feelings as the biggest reason (see February's post on Dads).  "Mothers should be educated about assessing the adequacy of milk supply by listening for an audible swallow, noting urine production by the number of diapers changed per day, and by recording weight gain at well-child visits."  Easy enough?  Not really, even if you're informed.

Imagine: you are in your first week of trying to breastfeed your new baby. Of course, you can't see the milk, and you have yet to learn your baby's feeding cues. Your newborn, like many, is very sleepy, and often falls asleep at the breast, leaving you wondering whether he is full or just got tired of trying to extract nonexistent milk.  You are counting pee diapers; but premium diapers feel so dry--does that really count as a pee?  He screams for food 45 minutes after a feeding, causing you to question whether he got enough at the last feeding.   At his well-baby visit, he comes in at the 30th percentile for weight (based on averages of both breastfed AND formula-fed babies).  The pediatrician says it's fine, but you are definitely concerned now that he isn't getting enough milk.  In a moment of panic, you feed him some formula.  The formula brings you a sense of relief because now you are certain your baby is getting the calories he needs.  It's comforting to view and measure the feeds.  Formula supplementing becomes part of your routine.  Meanwhile, your body is adjusting its supply to the milk demanded by the baby.  Since the baby, sated by formula, demands less, your body makes less.  Concerned still, you supplement a little more.  Eventually, it begins to feel like nursing is just for comfort, and maybe, you stop.

It's a vicious cycle.  And maybe you never had a supply problem at all!  It is easy to understand how this can happen, given how powerful the need is for a new mother to nourish her baby.   Of course, supply problems can be and are real in many cases, but the treatment for low supply is more nursing, not less.  In yet another situation, the combo of support and information is the key: knowing the signs of a well-fed baby AND having someone there to coach you along saying, "He's eating well, and you're doing great."


Arora, S.; McJunkin, C.; Wehrer, J.; Kuhn, P. “Major Factors Influencing Breastfeeding Rates: Mother’s Perception of Father’s Attitude and Milk Supply.” From the Family Medicine Department and the Research Center, Hamot Medical Center, Erie, Pennsylvania. 2000.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Formula-feeding support


If two-thirds of new moms initiate breastfeeding, the other third feeds formula right from the start.  What’s more, only 7.2% exclusively breastfed for six or more months (CDC, 2008); the 2005 Infant Feeding Survey in Britain showed that only 1% of babies were exclusively breastfed for one year.  That means that the vast majority of babies eat some formula during their lives.

Given this, we would expect that formula-feeding moms would have plenty of information and support.  However, according to a 2009 survey of data on formula feeding, “Many mothers who bottle-feed their babies reported receiving little information on bottle-feeding and did not feel empowered to make decisions…some healthcare providers noted that the WHO/Unicef code discourages active dissemination about bottle feeding.”  (Lakshman, 2009.)

The result of moms being uninformed is that hygiene and safety guidelines in bottle-feeding aren’t always followed. This includes using warm tap water, heating prepared bottles in the microwave, and over or under concentrating feeds.  Some mothers also changed formulas frequently which is not recommended. (Lakshman, 2009.)

Anecdotally, when I left the hospital with my newborn, there was not one document on formula feeding in the reams of paper I received on all things baby, nor had anyone at the hospital discussed it with me.  I went by the instructions on the can, though I still don’t know what the risks are if I, say, over concentrate feeds by adding the water after the powder.

It would be a shame if part of the effort to encourage breastfeeding meant a failure to address the needs of bottle-feeding moms.  Withholding of information about alternatives isn’t usually the best way to encourage something.  I think we’d be better off if new moms knew at least a little about both feeding methods, because most of us will feed formula at some point, and we owe it to our kids to get it right.

1.     Lakshman, R; Ogilvie, D; Ong, K. K. “Mothers’ experiences of bottle-feeding: a systematic review of qualitative and quantitative studies.” Archives of Disease in Childhood, 12 May 2009. 
2.  Center for Disease Control. 2008 Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance, National Summary of Breastfeeding Indicators, Children Aged less than 5 years [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/pednss/pednss_tables/html/pednss_national_table3.htm

Monday, February 15, 2010

Dads

A 2000 study of new moms in Pennsylvania showed that the primary reason for initiating bottle-feeding over breastfeeding was the mother’s perception of the father’s preference (Arora, 2000).  Dads’ education and interest in baby feeding naturally have a big impact on the decision to breastfeed and the success of the breastfeeding effort.  It can be direct: a knowledgeable dad can play a direct role in baby feeding, such as by observing and assisting with latching positions.  It can be indirect too: a supportive dad gives encouragement and anticipates needs (Tohotoa, 2009), like taking care of housework or holding the baby while mom showers or rests. Another highlight of the 2009 Tohotoa study was that “fathers participating in the study all wanted to be involved with parenting and parenthood, but many of them felt they were unprepared and lacked the relevant information to be effective in their parenting role.” If we could do a better job of educating fathers, moms could be more empowered in baby feeding. 

I would never have gotten as far as I did with nursing if it weren’t for Sam’s dad, Max.  The two of us together agreed while I was pregnant to breastfeed, based on evidence that breast milk is healthier for the baby. During the two weeks we spent trying to breastfeed, he was extremely supportive.  He sat in on sessions with the lactation consultant and reminded me of her advice during feeding sessions.  He provided physical support, arranging the baby, pillows, and even Sam’s jaw and lips, helping get the job done, around the clock.    Moreover, he provided critical emotional support, listening patiently to my outpourings about how much pain I was in, how awful I felt, how desperately I wanted to feed my baby. And when we thought we would need to switch to formula, he supported that too.  Later, when I started pumping full-time, he continued to encourage me and took care of Sam while I pumped.  He deserves a big chunk of the credit for us eventually finding a system that worked. 

He told me recently that he never really understood exactly how I felt.  I tried to explain the pain and resulting emotional torment as presenting your arm, once every two hours, to have a cigarette put out on it--for the first few times, you can endure it, but eventually you begin to feel beaten down, depressed, intimidated.  I think he understood the analogy, but the truth is that real empathy can only come from other women who have been through it.  (More on support from other women later.)  Nonetheless, he was a full partner in every way he could be, and my son and I are lucky to have him.

1.      Tohotoa, J.; Maycock, B.; Hauck, Y. L.; Howat, P.; Burns, S; Binns, C. W. “Dads make a difference: an exploratory study of paternal support for breastfeeding in Perth, Western Australia.” International Breastfeeding Journal 2009, 4:15.

2.     Arora, S.; McJunkin, C.; Wehrer, J.; Kuhn, P. “Major Factors Influencing Breastfeeding Rates: Mother’s Perception of Father’s Attitude and Milk Supply.” From the Family Medicine Department and the Research Center, Hamot Medical Center, Erie, Pennsylvania. 2000.