Lately I've been hearing the phrase "risks of not breastfeeding" a lot. This is different than talking about "pros and cons of breastfeeding," as it is often presented. It was presented this way in the book I used during pregnancy, From the Hips by Rebecca Odes and Ceridwen Morris, which cited "more margaritas" as a "pro" to formula feeding; I think it was meant to be irreverent or humorous, but given what I know now about the significant health differences between the average formula-fed baby and the average breastfed baby, I question its validity. (Though, this book did a good job overall on the whole in its breastfeeding section.)
What if infant formula were considered an intervention by the medical community? Then, the risks of using it could be listed, much like a medicine. The choice still belongs to the mother, but the argument is framed such that breastfeeding is the norm and formula is the intervention. For example, the natural way to keep our cholesterol low is eating a healthy diet high in fiber and low in saturated fat. But for some people, that isn't enough, and for others, sticking to a diet isn't feasible. In either case, there is medicine to help, for which the patient can understand the risks.
Of course, the "patient" in the case of breastfeeding is not one's self but one's infant. Does this change our responsibilities? It it irresponsible not to attempt to breastfeed? I'm not sure, but even if it is, it doesn't seem right to place this kind of accountability with individual moms when our society fails to support it.
Showing posts with label formula. Show all posts
Showing posts with label formula. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 25, 2010
Sunday, May 9, 2010
Supply
The second biggest reason moms choose to formula-feed is not being able to tell if the baby is getting enough milk, according to the same article (Arora, 2000) that cited fathers' feelings as the biggest reason (see February's post on Dads). "Mothers should be educated about assessing the adequacy of milk supply by listening for an audible swallow, noting urine production by the number of diapers changed per day, and by recording weight gain at well-child visits." Easy enough? Not really, even if you're informed.
Imagine: you are in your first week of trying to breastfeed your new baby. Of course, you can't see the milk, and you have yet to learn your baby's feeding cues. Your newborn, like many, is very sleepy, and often falls asleep at the breast, leaving you wondering whether he is full or just got tired of trying to extract nonexistent milk. You are counting pee diapers; but premium diapers feel so dry--does that really count as a pee? He screams for food 45 minutes after a feeding, causing you to question whether he got enough at the last feeding. At his well-baby visit, he comes in at the 30th percentile for weight (based on averages of both breastfed AND formula-fed babies). The pediatrician says it's fine, but you are definitely concerned now that he isn't getting enough milk. In a moment of panic, you feed him some formula. The formula brings you a sense of relief because now you are certain your baby is getting the calories he needs. It's comforting to view and measure the feeds. Formula supplementing becomes part of your routine. Meanwhile, your body is adjusting its supply to the milk demanded by the baby. Since the baby, sated by formula, demands less, your body makes less. Concerned still, you supplement a little more. Eventually, it begins to feel like nursing is just for comfort, and maybe, you stop.
It's a vicious cycle. And maybe you never had a supply problem at all! It is easy to understand how this can happen, given how powerful the need is for a new mother to nourish her baby. Of course, supply problems can be and are real in many cases, but the treatment for low supply is more nursing, not less. In yet another situation, the combo of support and information is the key: knowing the signs of a well-fed baby AND having someone there to coach you along saying, "He's eating well, and you're doing great."
Arora, S.; McJunkin, C.; Wehrer, J.; Kuhn, P. “Major Factors Influencing Breastfeeding Rates: Mother’s Perception of Father’s Attitude and Milk Supply.” From the Family Medicine Department and the Research Center, Hamot Medical Center, Erie, Pennsylvania. 2000.
Imagine: you are in your first week of trying to breastfeed your new baby. Of course, you can't see the milk, and you have yet to learn your baby's feeding cues. Your newborn, like many, is very sleepy, and often falls asleep at the breast, leaving you wondering whether he is full or just got tired of trying to extract nonexistent milk. You are counting pee diapers; but premium diapers feel so dry--does that really count as a pee? He screams for food 45 minutes after a feeding, causing you to question whether he got enough at the last feeding. At his well-baby visit, he comes in at the 30th percentile for weight (based on averages of both breastfed AND formula-fed babies). The pediatrician says it's fine, but you are definitely concerned now that he isn't getting enough milk. In a moment of panic, you feed him some formula. The formula brings you a sense of relief because now you are certain your baby is getting the calories he needs. It's comforting to view and measure the feeds. Formula supplementing becomes part of your routine. Meanwhile, your body is adjusting its supply to the milk demanded by the baby. Since the baby, sated by formula, demands less, your body makes less. Concerned still, you supplement a little more. Eventually, it begins to feel like nursing is just for comfort, and maybe, you stop.
It's a vicious cycle. And maybe you never had a supply problem at all! It is easy to understand how this can happen, given how powerful the need is for a new mother to nourish her baby. Of course, supply problems can be and are real in many cases, but the treatment for low supply is more nursing, not less. In yet another situation, the combo of support and information is the key: knowing the signs of a well-fed baby AND having someone there to coach you along saying, "He's eating well, and you're doing great."
Arora, S.; McJunkin, C.; Wehrer, J.; Kuhn, P. “Major Factors Influencing Breastfeeding Rates: Mother’s Perception of Father’s Attitude and Milk Supply.” From the Family Medicine Department and the Research Center, Hamot Medical Center, Erie, Pennsylvania. 2000.
Labels:
0-3 months,
breastfeeding,
formula,
supply,
support
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Formula-feeding support
If two-thirds of new moms initiate breastfeeding, the other third feeds formula right from the start. What’s more, only 7.2% exclusively breastfed for six or more months (CDC, 2008); the 2005 Infant Feeding Survey in Britain showed that only 1% of babies were exclusively breastfed for one year. That means that the vast majority of babies eat some formula during their lives.
Given this, we would expect that formula-feeding moms would have plenty of information and support. However, according to a 2009 survey of data on formula feeding, “Many mothers who bottle-feed their babies reported receiving little information on bottle-feeding and did not feel empowered to make decisions…some healthcare providers noted that the WHO/Unicef code discourages active dissemination about bottle feeding.” (Lakshman, 2009.)
The result of moms being uninformed is that hygiene and safety guidelines in bottle-feeding aren’t always followed. This includes using warm tap water, heating prepared bottles in the microwave, and over or under concentrating feeds. Some mothers also changed formulas frequently which is not recommended. (Lakshman, 2009.)
Anecdotally, when I left the hospital with my newborn, there was not one document on formula feeding in the reams of paper I received on all things baby, nor had anyone at the hospital discussed it with me. I went by the instructions on the can, though I still don’t know what the risks are if I, say, over concentrate feeds by adding the water after the powder.
It would be a shame if part of the effort to encourage breastfeeding meant a failure to address the needs of bottle-feeding moms. Withholding of information about alternatives isn’t usually the best way to encourage something. I think we’d be better off if new moms knew at least a little about both feeding methods, because most of us will feed formula at some point, and we owe it to our kids to get it right.
1. Lakshman, R; Ogilvie, D; Ong, K. K. “Mothers’ experiences of bottle-feeding: a systematic review of qualitative and quantitative studies.” Archives of Disease in Childhood, 12 May 2009.
2. Center for Disease Control. 2008 Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance, National Summary of Breastfeeding Indicators, Children Aged less than 5 years [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/pednss/pednss_tables/html/pednss_national_table3.htm
2. Center for Disease Control. 2008 Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance,
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)